Are you an agent or a customer?
Making the Right Move: Understanding Whether to Rent or Buy in Colorado Springs (2025 Edition)
Written by Beaton Brothers Property Experts | Trusted Colorado Springs Realtors
Publish Date: October 20, 2025
Trying to decide whether it’s smarter to rent or buy in Colorado Springs this year? You’re not alone.
With median home prices around $479,000, average rents near $2,200, and a more balanced market taking shape,
many locals are re-evaluating their next step.
This guide from Beaton Brothers Property Experts breaks down real 2025 numbers, compares rent vs. mortgage costs,
and helps you see which choice makes the most sense for your goals — whether that’s flexibility today or building equity for tomorrow.
Is It Better to Rent or Buy in Colorado Springs? A Real Look at 2025’s Housing Market
Introduction, why the rent vs buy Colorado Springs decision matters in 2025
In 2025, the rent vs buy Colorado Springs question is one of the biggest financial crossroads for local residents. With rents rising and home prices stabilizing, many renters are wondering if now is the right time to buy. The answer depends on your goals, budget, and how long you plan to stay.
At Beaton Brothers Property Experts, we help renters and first-time buyers evaluate both sides clearly. Our veteran-led team provides honest guidance and local data so you can make confident, informed decisions about your next move.
Colorado Springs market snapshot
- Median home price: $479,450
- Average single-family rent: approximately $2,200 per month
- Market type: soft buyer’s market with increased inventory
- Average mortgage rates: 6.4% (VA), 6.75% (FHA), 7.1% (Conventional)
According to Realtor.com, Colorado Springs remains one of the nation’s top-performing housing markets due to consistent population growth and strong employment sectors.
At Beaton Brothers Property Experts, we monitor these trends daily to help clients time their purchases or renewals strategically.
Renting in Colorado Springs, why it feels easier now
For many, renting offers short-term comfort and flexibility in a shifting market:
- Lower monthly cost: Rent payments remain several hundred dollars below typical mortgage payments.
- Flexibility: Easier to relocate for work or PCS orders.
- Minimal upkeep: Maintenance and repairs are handled by landlords or property managers.
- Lower upfront cost: No down payment or closing fees.
Renting makes sense if you’re unsure about your long-term plans or need time to build savings and credit. Still, it’s important to understand how this compares with owning over time.
Buying in Colorado Springs, where the long term math starts to work
While renting may look cheaper month-to-month, buying a home offers long-term financial and lifestyle benefits. Many clients who work with Beaton Brothers Property Experts discover that homeownership builds equity faster than they expected.
- Equity growth: Every payment increases your ownership stake.
- Appreciation: Even a 3% annual rise on a $479,000 home can add over $75,000 in value after five years.
- Payment stability: A fixed-rate mortgage locks in principal and interest while rents rise.
- Personal freedom: Update, paint, and improve your home without landlord restrictions.
Rent vs mortgage comparison in Colorado Springs
| Scenario | Down Payment | Interest Rate | Est. Monthly Payment (with taxes & insurance) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Renting a 3-bedroom home | — | — | $2,200 |
| VA Loan (0% down) | $0 | 6.4% | ≈ $3,400 |
| FHA Loan (10% down) | $47,945 | 6.75% | ≈ $3,370 |
| Conventional Loan (20% down) | $95,890 | 7.1% | ≈ $2,920 |
Educational Note: All figures are approximate and for illustration purposes only. Contact a licensed lender for personalized rates and payments.
Five year cost and wealth projection
| Scenario | 5-Year Cost | Estimated Equity + Appreciation | Net Wealth Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rent ($2,200 + 3% annual increases) | ≈ $140,000 | $0 | $0 |
| VA Loan (0%) | ≈ $204,000 | ≈ $108,000 | +$108,000 |
| FHA Loan (10%) | ≈ $202,000 | ≈ $103,000 | +$103,000 |
| Conventional Loan (20%) | ≈ $196,000 | ≈ $98,000 | +$98,000 |
Educational Note: Projections exclude maintenance, utilities, HOA, improvements, and selling costs. For education only.
When renting makes more sense in 2025
- Short-term stay under 3 years
- Not enough savings for a comfortable cushion after closing
- Uncertain job or PCS schedule
- Preference for low-maintenance living
At Beaton Brothers Property Experts, we always encourage clients to buy only when it fits their lifestyle and financial comfort — never out of pressure or fear of missing out.
What this means for you right now
- Staying 5+ years? Buying could build wealth faster.
- Need flexibility? Keep renting but plan strategically.
- VA-eligible? Use your 0% down benefit and negotiate seller credits.
- Ask about CHFA and lender assistance programs to reduce upfront costs.
Beaton Brothers Property Experts can walk you through each step, from comparing loan options to reviewing listings that fit your financial plan. No pressure — just clarity.
FAQs
Is it cheaper to rent than buy in Colorado Springs right now?
Yes, monthly rent is often lower, but homeowners gain equity and stability over time. It depends on your timeline and comfort level.
How much down payment do I need?
You don’t need 20%. VA = 0%, FHA = 3.5–10%, Conventional = 3–20%. Programs like CHFA can help with assistance.
What credit score should I have before buying?
Many programs accept mid-600s and up. We can connect you with trusted local lenders to prequalify quickly.
Are rents still rising in 2025?
Yes. Most neighborhoods have seen continued rent growth, especially for single-family homes.
What if mortgage rates drop after I buy?
You can refinance later. Focus on finding the right home now — rates can always change later.
How long should I stay in a home for buying to make sense?
Generally 5–7 years. That window allows appreciation and equity to offset buying and selling costs.
Take the Next Step with Beaton Brothers Property Experts
The rent vs buy Colorado Springs decision doesn’t have to be overwhelming. Our local, veteran-led team is here to guide you through every step — from exploring loan options to finding your perfect home.
- Personalized rent vs buy breakdown using your actual numbers
- Connections to top VA, FHA, and Conventional lenders
- Assistance with CHFA, seller credits, and rate buydowns
- Access to our RealScout MLS search with live listings
Call or Text (719) 751-6585 to schedule a FREE real estate consultation to discuss what renting vs buying could look like for you.
Or explore homes right now through our interactive RealScout search (HERE) updated daily with Colorado Springs’ newest listings.
About Beaton Brothers Property Experts
Beaton Brothers Property Experts is a veteran-led real estate team in Colorado Springs, Colorado, specializing in residential sales, new construction, VA loans, and relocation services. Founded by Charles and Laura Beaton, our team pairs deep local expertise with modern marketing and proven systems to help buyers and sellers move with confidence.
We are trusted Colorado Springs real estate experts serving neighborhoods such as Banning Lewis Ranch, Flying Horse, Meridian Ranch, Wolf Ranch, and Broadmoor, as well as Monument, Fountain, Peyton, Falcon, and Manitou Springs.
Explore Colorado Springs homes |
Get your free home valuation
Serving El Paso County and surrounding areas. Office: 1755 Telstar Dr #300, Colorado Springs, CO 80920.
Brokered by Real Broker, LLC.
Phone: (719) 751-6585
Email: [email protected]
Educational notes and disclosures
Educational intent: This content is for general education only. All figures use October 2025 assumptions and rounded estimates. Consult licensed professionals for personalized advice.
Fair Housing: Beaton Brothers Property Experts supports equal housing opportunity and complies with all Fair Housing laws in Colorado and federally.
Brokerage disclosure: Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Beaton Brothers Property Experts is licensed under Real Broker LLC. Not financial, tax, or legal advice.